Appleton, Wisconsin, and his original escape
History’s most celebrated magician was born Erik Weisz on March 24, 1874, in Budapest, Hungary. He was four years old when his family set sail for America aboard the steamship Frisia, arriving in New York on July 3, 1878. Eric’s father, Mayer Samuel Weiss, was already there. His mother Cecilia, nee Steiner, answered the immigration officer in German, so her appointed surname became Weiss and the whole family was given a raft of new “German” names: Herman for Armin, Nathan for Natan, William for Gottfried Vilmos, Theo for Ferencz Dezso and, for Erik, the altogether more cumbersome Ehrich.
Cecilia had two months to spend with her mother and sisters in New York, and then in September she and her family moved on to join Mayer in Appleton, Wisconsin. There this story begins, with a poor, diminutive Jewish boy immigrating to WASP America with his swelling family, whose father could barely speak English and whose mother never did learn how. He was already off to a rough start, and would soon learn that he couldn’t be backward about coming forward.
The Houdini boys after Harry hit the big time: From left, brothers Leopold, Theodore (who became the magician Hardeen), Ehrich, William and Nathan.
Appleton was a young town practically on the wild frontier, and a quirky one at that. It had a college and an opera house, but it didn’t have sewers or running water. Apart from its odd character, it’s never had a lot going for it. Senator Joe McCarthy came from Appleton too, and he’s nothing to be proud about. Willem Dafoe is another local, but he didn’t even bother revisiting until many years after becoming a movie star. In Google Earth imagery, as of mid-2007, the town remained a blurry mush, and in circumstances like that, imagination comes in handy, as it did for McCarthy, Dafoe, Ehrich Weiss and for the fourth famous Appletonian, Edna Ferber.
The future author of “Show Boat” and “Cimarron” and the book that became my favourite James Dean picture, “Giant”, was also of Hungarian Jewish origins, and she reckoned the way to become a successful writer was to start out as a newspaper reporter. (It’s a theory I’ve been testing for three decades.)
In July 1904 she was working for the Appleton Crescent when the famous Harry Houdini came home for a visit. He’d been back once before, in the spring of 1897, with a touring troupe called the Rogers Orpheum Stars. They put on a show at the local opera house, and Houdini escaped from three pairs of handcuffs in five minutes. Seven years later he was one of the world’s most celebrated entertainers.
Edna found him in a drugstore on College Avenue and interviewed him on the spot. The article she wrote is online, though she doesn’t say what he was doing in the drugstore — maybe just chilling at the soda fountain.
“I am earning, now, from $900 to $2,000 a week,” he told her, “but my first performance brought me slightly less than that. It took place in an old field across the track in the Sixth Ward and I did a contortionist act, giving three performances, for which [my manager] paid me exactly 35 cents.”
She was impressed by his sinewy physique, the result of being a track star in his youth (biographer Kenneth Silverman claimed that all but one of those medals on his chest in the photo were fakes) and sampling a bit of trapeze work. But Ferber was even more amazed at his dexterity: he ended their conversation by offering her a gumball from the drugstore’s vending machine, which he’d idly unlocked while they were gabbing.
Today in the same part of town is Houdini Plaza, inaugurated in 1985 at the former site of the Weiss home, which was above a downtown store. There’s a towering sculpture by Richard Wolter called “Metamorphosis”, around which magicians often put on shows, including famous ones like Doug Henning, David Copperfield and Penn & Teller.
There’s also a bar called Houdini’s Lounge, and many bronze plaques memorialising young Harry.
Further along the road at 330 East College Avenue is the History Museum at the Castle, usually referred to as the Outagamie Museum because it’s run by the Outagamie County Historical Society. It has a Houdini Historical Center featuring ongoing exhibits, and it looks pretty good from its website.
William Kalush and Larry Sloman made ample use of its apparently vast archives for their 2006 biography “The Secret Life of Houdini”. The photo here shows museum staff in the 1970s unpacking the famous Milk Can from which Houdini escaped a thousand times. Also among the treasures is Harry’s first book of press clippings, which would be a real mess after all these years had the pages not been lovingly “deacidified” here and encased in a chemically inert polyester sleeve.
Another website I’ve seen relates that the town used to host magicians from all over the country at its annual Houdini Days festival. It wasn’t made clear why they abandoned the event, but they might want to consider reviving it. Houdini is making news again these days.
Father Weiss used to make soap in Hungary and then begun practising law, but when he linked up with his friend in Appleton and was told the local Jews needed a rabbi, and he readily took the position. Things were fine for a while, and two more children came along, Leopold and Gladys, but eventually Mayer’s adult flock wanted someone with a little more pizzazz, and they got someone.
The family moved to Milwaukee in late 1882 and stayed there for four years, residing at several addresses while Ehrich sold newspapers and shined shoes. Mayer left the family behind and went looking for work elsewhere, mostly teaching the good book. At one point Ehrich, who at least learned from his old man how to “put on a show”, tried the same thing — hitting the road, that is.
When he died Houdini was making plans to establish a University of Magic in New York and even had a course list drawn up. Maybe someday someone will actually follow through on the idea. For now, the kids in Appleton can start small — at Houdini Elementary School. (No, they don’t teach them tricks. Not knowingly, anyway.)
The school’s name was apparently chosen by its first pupils, and its official colours are the red and black of a stereotypical magician’s cape!


